Skip to content
CMHC Home Canada Mortgage
and Housing Corporation
  • Sign In or Register
  • Français
  • MENU
MENU
× Français
  • Home
  • Professionals
    • Project funding and mortgage financing
      • Funding programs
        • Affordable Housing Fund
        • Affordable Housing Innovation Fund
        • Apartment Construction Loan Program
        • Canada Greener Affordable Housing
        • Community (social) housing
        • Federal Lands Initiative
        • Funding for Indigenous housing
        • Housing Supply Challenge
        • Innovation and research
        • National Housing Strategy Project Profiles
        • Rapid Housing Initiative
      • Mortgage Loan Insurance Products
        • Homeowner and Small Rental Mortgage Loan Insurance
          • CMHC Purchase
          • CMHC Improvement
          • CMHC Income Property
          • CMHC Refinance
          • CMHC Newcomers
          • CMHC Self-Employed
          • CMHC Portability
          • Eco Products for Lenders
        • Multi-Unit and Rental Housing
          • MLI Select
        • Default, claims and properties for sale
        • Underwriting centre
        • emili
        • NHA approved lenders
        • Calculating GDS / TDS
        • How to recognize and report mortgage fraud
        • Contact mortgage loan insurance
        • Insured Mortgage Purchase Program (IMPP)
      • Securitization
        • NHA Mortgage Backed Securities
        • Canada Mortgage Bonds
        • Canadian registered covered bonds
        • Blockchain in the housing industry
    • Housing markets, data and research
      • CMHC Reports Calendar
      • Housing markets
        • Housing market reports
        • Mortgage market and consumer reports
        • Fall 2024 Rental Market Report
      • Housing research
        • Consultations
          • Prohibition on the Purchase of Residential Property by Non-Canadians Act
            • Prohibition on the Purchase of Residential Property by Non-Canadians Act – Frequently asked questions
        • Housing research reports
        • Housing surveys
          • Mortgage consumer surveys
        • Research awards and scholarships
        • Understanding core housing need
        • Collaborative Housing Research Network
      • Housing data
        • Data tables
          • Household characteristics data
          • Housing market data
          • Mortgage and debt data
          • Rental market data
        • Housing market information portal
        • Residential Mortgage Industry Data Dashboard
        • CMHC licence agreement for the use of data
        • Housing Knowledge Centre
    • Industry innovation and leadership
      • Housing innovation
      • Our Partners
        • Partnerships
        • Federal, Provincial and Territorial Forum on Housing
      • Industry collaboration
        • Expert Community on Housing (ECoH)
      • Industry expertise
        • Affordable housing
        • Indigenous housing
        • Senior housing
        • Accessible and adaptable housing
        • Developing sustainable housing
        • Resources for mortgage professionals
        • CMHC newsletters
    • Events and speakers
      • Conferences
        • 2024 National Housing Conference
          • About
          • National Housing Conference - Agenda
          • Location
          • InnoZone
          • Details for participants
      • Speakers’ bureau
        • Kevin Hughes
  • Consumers
    • Buying a home
      • Homebuying calculators
        • Mortgage calculator
        • Affordability calculator
        • Debt service calculator
      • Buying guides
        • Homebuying step by step
        • CMHC's condominium buyer's guide
      • Mortgage loan insurance for consumers
        • What is CMHC mortgage loan insurance?
        • Do I qualify for mortgage loan insurance?
        • CMHC mortgage loan insurance costs
        • CMHC's Eco Products
          • CMHC’s Eco Improvement
          • CMHC Eco Plus
        • CMHC — home renovation financing options
        • FAQs — mortgage loan insurance
      • Incentives for homebuyers
      • Newcomers
      • The First-Time Home Buyer Incentive
    • Owning a home
      • Manage your mortgage
        • Mortgage fraud
        • Mortgage planning tips
        • Plan and manage your mortgage
        • Your credit report
        • Your home value
      • Aging in place
        • Housing options for Seniors
        • Housing and finance tips
        • Mortgage financing options for people 55+
        • Preventing fraud and financial abuse
    • Renting a home
      • I want to rent
        • Things to consider before renting
        • Types of housing for rent in Canada
        • Finding or advertising a rental property
        • Visiting the rental property
        • Lease and rental agreements
        • Signing the lease
        • Credit checks and bad credit
        • Rental payments and deposits
        • Roommates and pets
      • I am renting
        • Moving day
        • Landlord/Tenant responsibilities
        • Inspections
        • Maintenance and repairs
        • Complaints and evictions
        • Rent increases
        • When you can't pay rent
        • Renewing or terminating the lease
        • Moving out
      • One-Time Top-Up to the Canada Housing Benefit
      • COVID‑19: eviction bans and suspensions to support renters
  • About CMHC
    • CMHC’s goals, values and commitment to housing
    • Discover Life at CMHC
    • Management and governance
      • Speakers’ bureau
      • CMHC's Annual Public Meeting
      • CMHC’s board of directors and committees
      • Our management committee
      • Pension governance
        • Pension overview
        • Key roles and responsibilities
        • Annual reports
    • Corporate reporting
      • CMHC’s 2023 Annual Report
      • Program evaluation
      • Quarterly financial reports
      • Joint auditors special examination report to CMHC board 2018
      • CMHC’s Insured Mortgage Deferral
      • Corporate Plan Summary
      • Transparency
        • Access to information and privacy protection
        • Accessibility at CMHC
        • Accessibility feedback process
        • Briefing materials
        • Procurement
          • Vendor Diversity Program
        • Travel, hospitality and conference expenditures
    • Contact us
      • Contact mortgage loan insurance
      • Regional offices
      • Granville lsland
      • Indigenous and the North Housing Solutions
      • National office
      • Holiday service hours
  • Media Newsroom
  • National Housing Strategy
    • What is the strategy?
      • About the initiatives
      • How to apply
      • Help and resources
      • Priority areas for action
      • The National Housing Strategy Glossary of Common Terms
      • The Strategy in Action
    • Federal/Provincial/Territorial housing agreements
    • Other funding and financing opportunities
  • The Housing Observer
  • Canada’s Housing Podcast
  • Careers
  • Housing Knowledge Centre
 
  • Home
  • Professionals
  • Housing markets, data and research
  • Housing research
  • Housing research reports
  • Housing finance system
  • Mortgage Deferral Series
  • Consumer Credit Scores and Mortgage Deferrals
  • Save
  • Share
Save Icon

SAVE TO MY FOLDER

Consumer Credit Scores and Mortgage Deferrals

SAVE
Close this Window   |   Manage my Folder
Save Icon

SAVE TO MY FOLDER

Consumer Credit Scores and Mortgage Deferrals

Done Done!
Close this Window   |   Manage my Folder
Share icon

Share via

  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • Mail
  • print
  • CopyLink

SuccessCopyLinkVersionLink copied

Share icon

Share via

  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • Mail
  • print
  • CopyLink

SuccessCopyLinkVersionLink copied

share icon

Mail-blue Share via Email

Did You Know?

You can include an email signature?

Register | Sign In

×
Google Captcha Loader
share icon

Mail-blue Share via Email

Done Done!
Close this window

Consumer Credit Scores and Mortgage Deferrals

An analysis of trends in the credit scores of consumers before they deferred mortgage payments.

Show Guide Chapters
  • Mortgage Deferral Series
  • Deferred Mortgages by Borrower’s Employment Industry
  • Duration of Mortgage Deferrals
  • Consumer Debt Deferrals by Lender Group
  • Consumer Credit Scores and Mortgage Deferrals
  • Deferrals of Insured and Uninsured Mortgages

This analysis examines trends in the credit scores of consumers before they deferred mortgage payments. The data is from the credit rating agency Equifax Canada, and is as reported to that agency.1 The data covers approximately 80% to 85% of the Canadian market for residential mortgages and includes both insured and uninsured mortgages.

Highlight of findings

  • Borrowers who deferred mortgage payments, on average, had a lower credit score before the pandemic than those who did not. The difference is observed for all age groups.
  • Borrowers who deferred mortgage payments had experienced a decline in credit score after mortgage origination and prior to the pandemic.
  • It is likely that some of these borrowers had already been in a weakened financial situation before the pandemic hit.
  • Relying on borrowers' credit information obtained at mortgage origination may not be sufficient for the ongoing monitoring of credit risk. This is due to information becoming stale over time.

Credit scores are often used to assess consumers’ creditworthiness and ability to repay their debt. Mortgage deferrals during the pandemic should not negatively impact a consumer’s credit score reported by Equifax Canada.

We analyzed the trend in consumer credit scores before the start of the COVID-19 pandemic. We wanted to understand the:

  • characteristics of borrowers who deferred mortgage payments
  • effectiveness of credit scores in indicating borrowers’ ability to repay

On average, borrowers who deferred mortgage payments had lower credit scores

We compared the credit scores of borrowers who deferred and didn’t defer their mortgage payments between March and October of 2020. Figure 1 shows the average credit scores for the 2 groups from February 2019 to February 2020, before the pandemic. The average credit score of those who would go on to defer mortgage payments was lower than that of borrowers who would not. The difference was close to 50 points in credit score.

Figure 1: Average credit score for consumers with mortgages

Figure 1. Average credit score for consumers with mortgages
Period Borrowers who deferred mortgage payments between March and October 2020 Borrowers who did not defer mortgage payments
2019-02 729 775
2019-03 728 774
2019-04 730 776
2019-05 729 776
2019-06 729 776
2019-07 729 776
2019-08 728 776
2019-09 728 776
2019-10 728 776
2019-11 728 777
2019-12 728 777
2020-01 727 777
2020-02 727 778

Source: Equifax Risk Score (ERS 2.0), Equifax Canada

We see this difference for all age groups. Overall, consumers’ credit scores increase as they get older. Within each age group, borrowers who deferred mortgage payments had, on average, a lower credit score than those who did not. Figure 2 shows the average credit score by age group as at February 2020, the month before the start of the COVID-19 pandemic.

Figure 2: Average credit score for consumers with mortgages, by age group, as at February 2020

Figure 2. Average credit score for consumers with mortgages, by age group, as at February 2020
Age group Borrowers who deferred mortgage payments between March and October 2020 Borrowers who did not defer mortgage payments
29 and younger 717 757
30 – 39 years old 724 774
40 – 49 years old 722 776
50 – 64 years old 734 786
65 and older 756 799

Source: Equifax Risk Score (ERS 2.0), Equifax Canada

The average credit score had decreased since mortgage origination for borrowers who later deferred mortgage payments

The difference in credit score between borrowers who did and those who did not defer mortgage payments stemmed from 2 factors:

  • At mortgage origination, the average credit score of borrowers who later deferred mortgage payments had been lower than that of borrowers who did not.2
  • After origination, the average credit score of borrowers who later deferred mortgage payments had decreased in relation to that of borrowers who did not.

Figure 3 shows the average change in consumer credit score during the period from when a borrower originated a mortgage to February 2020. For borrowers who deferred mortgage payments between March and October 2020, 45% of them had experienced a decline in their credit score since their mortgage origination. For the upper 2 age groups, the credit score had increased, on average, for borrowers who deferred payments. However, the level of the increase was smaller than that for borrowers who did not defer payments.

Figure 3: Difference in credit score between mortgage origination and February 2020, by age group

Figure 3. Difference in credit score between mortgage origination and February 2020, by age group
Age group Borrowers who deferred mortgage payments between March and October 2020 Borrowers who did not defer mortgage payments
29 and younger -5 15
30 – 39 years old -5 16
40 – 49 years old -4 16
50 – 64 years old 5 22
65 and older 8 22

Source: CMHC calculations using Equifax Canada data Equifax Risk Score (ERS 2.0)

We tracked a cohort of consumers who originated mortgages in the 6-month period from January to June 2015. The goal was to assess how fast credit scores changed after mortgage origination. We chose this cohort so that we could see how their credit scores evolved in the 5-year period up to February 2020.3

At mortgage origination, there was a small difference in credit score between borrowers who later deferred payments and those who didn’t. The difference grew bigger over time. The largest divergence actually occurred among those borrowers who had an initial credit score above 749, which was Equifax’s highest score range. Figure 4 shows the change in credit score after mortgage origination for these consumers. The credit score for people who later deferred mortgage payments had started to decline in the first 6 months after they took on a new mortgage (on average). The largest drop happened in the first 2 years after mortgage origination. The decreasing trend continued to February 2020.

Figure 4: Change in credit score after mortgage origination, consumers with mortgage originated in January to June 2015 and initial credit score above 749

Figure 4. Change in credit score after mortgage origination, consumers with mortgage originated in January to June 2015 and initial credit score above 749
Period Borrowers who deferred mortgage payments between March and October 2020 Borrowers who did not defer mortgage payments
2015-12 -9 -1
2016-06 -12 0
2016-12 -16 -1
2017-06 -17 -1
2017-12 -18 0
2018-06 -15 4
2018-12 -16 5
2019-06 -17 6
2019-12 -20 5
2020-02 -21 5

Source: CMHC calculations using Equifax Canada data Equifax Risk Score (ERS 2.0)

Our findings in this analysis suggest that credit scores are indicative of consumers’ debt repayment abilities. Borrowers who deferred mortgage payments from March to October 2020 had a lower credit score prior to the pandemic than those who didn’t. Some of these borrowers were likely to have been experiencing a weakened financial situation prior to the pandemic.

Relying on borrowers’ credit information obtained at mortgage origination may not be sufficient for the ongoing monitoring of credit risk. This is due to information becoming stale over time.

Footnotes

  1. This report uses data from the credit rating agency Equifax Canada on mortgage and non-mortgage consumer debt. For mortgages, the data covers approximately 80% to 85% of the Canadian market. CMHC did not access or receive personal identifiable information on individuals in producing the report. All figures are sourced from Equifax Canada unless otherwise stated. Unless otherwise noted, dollars are not adjusted for inflation. Equifax data is as is reported to the Bureau. The data may be revised at a later date due to Equifax data updates.
  2. It is needless to say that consumers who can qualify for a mortgage have good credit scores in general. The comparison in this analysis is among consumers with mortgages.
  3. For mortgages insured by CMHC homeowner transactional mortgage insurance, the average age of the deferred mortgages was about five years old.
Previous Consumer Debt Deferrals by Lender Group Next Deferrals of Insured and Uninsured Mortgages

Was this page relevant to your needs?

Thank you for your feedback!

How Can We Help?

Suggest an Improvement

Report a Bug

How Can We Help?

Suggest an Improvement

Please share your suggestion.

Google Captcha Loader

How Can We Help?

Report a Bug

Please describe the problem.

Google Captcha Loader

Thank you. Your feedback has been submitted.

Date Published: May 10, 2021

By Topic

  • Professionals
    • Project funding and mortgage financing
    • Housing markets data and research
    • Industry innovation and leadership
    • Events and speakers
  • Consumers
    • Home buying
    • Owning a home
    • Renting a home

About Us

  • CMHC's Story
  • Management and Governance
  • Our Partners
  • Corporate Reporting
  • Contact Us
  • Careers

More

  • CMHC Newsletters
  • CMHC Library
  • Housing Observer
  • Media Newsroom
  • CMHC and Accessible Housing
  • CMHC on Twitter
  • CMHC on LinkedIn
  • CMHC on Facebook
  • CMHC on Instagram
  • CMHC on YouTube
Privacy Policy    |    Terms and Conditions    |    Transparency    |    Accessibility Plan    |    Accessibility Feedback     Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation (CMHC) ©2025 
Canada
loader icon