Skip to content
CMHC Home Canada Mortgage
and Housing Corporation
  • Sign In or Register
  • Français
  • MENU
MENU
× Français
  • Home
  • Professionals
    • Project funding and mortgage financing
      • Funding programs
        • Affordable Housing Fund
        • Affordable Housing Innovation Fund
        • Apartment Construction Loan Program
        • Canada Greener Affordable Housing
        • Community (social) housing
        • Federal Lands Initiative
        • Funding for Indigenous housing
        • Housing Supply Challenge
        • Innovation and research
        • National Housing Strategy Project Profiles
        • Rapid Housing Initiative
      • Mortgage Loan Insurance Products
        • Homeowner and Small Rental Mortgage Loan Insurance
          • CMHC Purchase
          • CMHC Improvement
          • CMHC Income Property
          • CMHC Refinance
          • CMHC Newcomers
          • CMHC Self-Employed
          • CMHC Portability
          • Eco Products for Lenders
        • Multi-Unit and Rental Housing
          • MLI Select
        • Default, claims and properties for sale
        • Underwriting centre
        • emili
        • NHA approved lenders
        • Calculating GDS / TDS
        • How to recognize and report mortgage fraud
        • Contact mortgage loan insurance
        • Insured Mortgage Purchase Program (IMPP)
      • Securitization
        • NHA Mortgage Backed Securities
        • Canada Mortgage Bonds
        • Canadian registered covered bonds
        • Blockchain in the housing industry
    • Housing markets, data and research
      • CMHC Reports Calendar
      • Housing markets
        • Housing market reports
        • Mortgage market and consumer reports
        • Fall 2024 Rental Market Report
      • Housing research
        • Consultations
          • Prohibition on the Purchase of Residential Property by Non-Canadians Act
            • Prohibition on the Purchase of Residential Property by Non-Canadians Act – Frequently asked questions
        • Housing research reports
        • Housing surveys
          • Mortgage consumer surveys
        • Research awards and scholarships
        • Understanding core housing need
        • Collaborative Housing Research Network
      • Housing data
        • Data tables
          • Household characteristics data
          • Housing market data
          • Mortgage and debt data
          • Rental market data
        • Housing market information portal
        • Residential Mortgage Industry Data Dashboard
        • CMHC licence agreement for the use of data
        • Housing Knowledge Centre
    • Industry innovation and leadership
      • Housing innovation
      • Our Partners
        • Partnerships
        • Federal, Provincial and Territorial Forum on Housing
      • Industry collaboration
        • Expert Community on Housing (ECoH)
      • Industry expertise
        • Affordable housing
        • Indigenous housing
        • Senior housing
        • Accessible and adaptable housing
        • Developing sustainable housing
        • Resources for mortgage professionals
        • CMHC newsletters
    • Events and speakers
      • Conferences
        • 2024 National Housing Conference
          • About
          • National Housing Conference - Agenda
          • Location
          • InnoZone
          • Details for participants
      • Speakers’ bureau
        • Kevin Hughes
  • Consumers
    • Buying a home
      • Homebuying calculators
        • Mortgage calculator
        • Affordability calculator
        • Debt service calculator
      • Buying guides
        • Homebuying step by step
        • CMHC's condominium buyer's guide
      • Mortgage loan insurance for consumers
        • What is CMHC mortgage loan insurance?
        • Do I qualify for mortgage loan insurance?
        • CMHC mortgage loan insurance costs
        • CMHC's Eco Products
          • CMHC’s Eco Improvement
          • CMHC Eco Plus
        • CMHC — home renovation financing options
        • FAQs — mortgage loan insurance
      • Incentives for homebuyers
      • Newcomers
      • The First-Time Home Buyer Incentive
    • Owning a home
      • Manage your mortgage
        • Mortgage fraud
        • Mortgage planning tips
        • Plan and manage your mortgage
        • Your credit report
        • Your home value
      • Aging in place
        • Housing options for Seniors
        • Housing and finance tips
        • Mortgage financing options for people 55+
        • Preventing fraud and financial abuse
    • Renting a home
      • I want to rent
        • Things to consider before renting
        • Types of housing for rent in Canada
        • Finding or advertising a rental property
        • Visiting the rental property
        • Lease and rental agreements
        • Signing the lease
        • Credit checks and bad credit
        • Rental payments and deposits
        • Roommates and pets
      • I am renting
        • Moving day
        • Landlord/Tenant responsibilities
        • Inspections
        • Maintenance and repairs
        • Complaints and evictions
        • Rent increases
        • When you can't pay rent
        • Renewing or terminating the lease
        • Moving out
      • One-Time Top-Up to the Canada Housing Benefit
      • COVID‑19: eviction bans and suspensions to support renters
  • About CMHC
    • CMHC’s goals, values and commitment to housing
    • Discover Life at CMHC
    • Management and governance
      • Speakers’ bureau
      • CMHC's Annual Public Meeting
      • CMHC’s board of directors and committees
      • Our management committee
      • Pension governance
        • Pension overview
        • Key roles and responsibilities
        • Annual reports
    • Corporate reporting
      • CMHC’s 2023 Annual Report
      • Program evaluation
      • Quarterly financial reports
      • Joint auditors special examination report to CMHC board 2018
      • CMHC’s Insured Mortgage Deferral
      • Corporate Plan Summary
      • Transparency
        • Access to information and privacy protection
        • Accessibility at CMHC
        • Accessibility feedback process
        • Briefing materials
        • Procurement
          • Vendor Diversity Program
        • Travel, hospitality and conference expenditures
    • Contact us
      • Contact mortgage loan insurance
      • Regional offices
      • Granville lsland
      • Indigenous and the North Housing Solutions
      • National office
      • Holiday service hours
  • Media Newsroom
  • National Housing Strategy
    • What is the strategy?
      • About the initiatives
      • How to apply
      • Help and resources
      • Priority areas for action
      • The National Housing Strategy Glossary of Common Terms
      • The Strategy in Action
    • Federal/Provincial/Territorial housing agreements
    • Other funding and financing opportunities
  • The Housing Observer
  • Canada’s Housing Podcast
  • Careers
  • Housing Knowledge Centre
 
Save Icon

SAVE TO MY FOLDER

Effective Exit Strategies

SAVE
Close this Window   |   Manage my Folder
Save Icon

SAVE TO MY FOLDER

Effective Exit Strategies

Done Done!
Close this Window   |   Manage my Folder
Share icon

Share via

  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • Mail
  • print
  • CopyLink

SuccessCopyLinkVersionLink copied

Share icon

Share via

  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • Mail
  • print
  • CopyLink

SuccessCopyLinkVersionLink copied

share icon

Mail-blue Share via Email

Did You Know?

You can include an email signature?

Register | Sign In

×
Google Captcha Loader
share icon

Mail-blue Share via Email

Done Done!
Close this window
  • Home
  • Professionals
  • Housing markets, data and research
  • Housing research
  • Housing research reports
  • Housing finance system
  • Alternative Lenders Series
  • Effective Exit Strategies

Effective Exit Strategies

Exploring exit strategies of Ontario borrowers who secured their mortgage with an alternative lender.

  • Subscribe
    Subscribe
  • Save
  • Share
Show Guide Chapters
  • Alternative Lenders Series
  • Effective Exit Strategies

This analytical brief focuses on the financial paths of Ontario’s mortgage borrowers at the end of their mortgage loan term with an alternative lender. We explore the effectiveness of exit strategies.

Alternative lenders — a growing segment

From 2015 to 2020, alternative lenders held the national ranking of the fastest-growing segment in the Canadian mortgage lending industry. This is because of:

  • greater demand in the context of regulatory changes
  • rising housing prices
  • a low-interest-rate environment

The alternative lender portfolio increased from an estimated $9 billion in 2015 to $15 billion in 2020.

Their growth slowed significantly during the COVID-19 pandemic. This is because alternative lenders reacted to rapidly changing market conditions that led to numerous investors requesting equity redemptions.1

Their steady growth before the pandemic and their unconventional underwriting practices have raised questions regarding their potential to introduce new vulnerabilities into the housing finance system.

This is especially the case in regions where they have reached a larger market share, such as Ontario (figure 1).

One of the potential risks of mortgages secured through an alternative lender is that borrowers are unable to improve their financial situation. These borrowers are then committed to high-interest mortgage loans, resulting in long-term affordability issues.

Figure 1: As the fastest growing segment before the pandemic, alternative lenders have reached a considerable market share on mortgage transactions in Ontario

Sources: Teranet mortgage transactions data, CMHC calculations

Text Version

Year  Alternative share of mortgage transactions 
2006 11.28%
2007 9.76%
2008 8.09%
2009 8.59%
2010 8.45%
2011 8.31%
2012 9.38%
2013 10.81%
2014 10.72%
2015 10.34%
2016 10.47%
2017 12.72%
2018 14.83%
2019 14.66%
2020 12.28%
2021 12.36%

What is an exit strategy?

An exit strategy is a plan that is developed and assessed when a loan is originated as part of the underwriting process.

The exit strategy outlines the ability of the borrower to improve their financial situation and exit the alternative lending space at the end of the loan term. A borrower can sell their property as part of their exit strategy, without being delinquent on the loan.

The exit strategy is planned in conjunction with the borrower prior to the origination of the loan, typically as part of the approval process.

A well-defined exit strategy is vital. Some borrowers may face challenges paying higher interest rates on a mortgage loan for an extended period.

For this analytical brief, we consider an exit strategy to be effective if the borrower can contract a mortgage in the conventional lending space or sell their property. They would do these things without being delinquent on the alternative loan (figure 2).2

This indicator is important for monitoring the affordability implications of the alternative lending segment. If the effectiveness of exit strategies decreases, affordability may become a challenge for borrowers in alternative lending space. This is because mortgages secured through alternative lenders are typically more expensive than conventional mortgages. 

Figure 2: Four outcomes that result in an unsuccessful exit strategy or a successful one

Text Version

Unsuccessful exit strategy

  1. Borrower has a mortgage loan with alternative lender
  2. Borrower’s property is foreclosed

Successful exit strategy

  1. Borrower has a mortgage loan with conventional lender
  2. Borrower’s property is sold

Alternative lenders

Alternative mortgage lenders are an alternative to conventional mortgage lending institutions. Having their mortgage application rejected by conventional lenders is the main reason why borrowers use alternative mortgage lenders. Borrowers who tend to leverage alternative mortgage loans include:

  • the self-employed
  • employees with poor or no credit history
  • borrowers with short-term cash needs

Alternative lenders charge significantly higher interest rates than conventional lenders and typically offer interest-only loans.

There is a key underwriting difference between alternative and conventional lenders. For alternative lenders, the approval process is mainly driven by:

  • the equity built in the property
  • the borrowers’ cash flow in the short term

For conventional lenders, the borrower’s ability to make regular monthly payments until the loan is paid off is the main factor determining the approval process.

Their success relies on having an effective exit strategy that would determine:

  • the borrower’s ability to get approved by a conventional lender at the term of the loan
  • the ability to sell the property rapidly to repay the loan since long-term repayment to the alternative lender is unlikely to be sustainable for the borrower

Fast Facts

  • The majority of alternative mortgage borrowers (72%) had an effective exit strategy in place in 2020. These borrowers were able to get a loan with a conventional lender at the term of their alternative loan (64%) or sell their property without defaulting or the property being foreclosed (8.5%). This share has remained stable in 2021.
  • Properties with an alternative lender lien represent 80% of foreclosures in Ontario.
  • Foreclosures dropped significantly in 2020 (from 63 in 2019 to 23 in 2020) likely due to mortgage relief measures and lockdown measures, which put some activities on hold.

We adapted data from Teranet Inc. for this analysis. The data includes land registry variables matched from the Municipal Property Assessment Corporation of Ontario. This dataset only covers the Province of Ontario.

Key findings

Alternative mortgage loans had an effective exit strategy in 7 out of 10 loans

In 2020, nearly 32,245 alternative mortgage transactions were closed as borrowers either switched to another lender, or the properties were sold or foreclosed.

Of these, 72% had an effective exit strategy in place (figure 3). Over 23,000 borrowers successfully contracted a mortgage with a conventional lender, gaining access to a longer-term mortgage and lower interest rates.

Others were able to sell their property without being delinquent on the loan. This effective exit strategy indicator had been decreasing in the years leading up to the pandemic.

Figure 3: 1 out of 4 borrowers remained in the alternative lending space at the end of the mortgage term in 2020

Sources: Teranet mortgage transactions data, CMHC calculations

Text Version

  • Switched to a conventional lender: 63.6%
  • Switched or renewed with an alternative lender: 27.8%
  • Sold the property: 8.5%
  • Foreclosed the property: 0.1%

Between 2006 and 2015, approximately 80% of mortgages had an effective strategy. In 2019, this percentage had fallen to just around 70% (figure 4). From January to November 2021, the indicator remained stable relative to 2020 at 71%.

The decrease in changing to conventional lenders during the last decade is due in part to a series of macroprudential regulations and tighter underwriting standards. This makes it more difficult for borrowers to return to the conventional lending space.

Figure 4: The rate of success of the planned exit strategies has decreased by 10 percentage points since 2011

Sources: Teranet mortgage transactions data, CMHC calculations

Text Version

Year  % switched back to conventional lender   % property sold 
2006 63.11% 18.18%
2007 68.55% 15.37%
2008 69.47% 15.41%
2009 64.26% 17.23%
2010 66.14% 16.34%
2011 68.56% 14.24%
2012 59.90% 18.96%
2013 60.33% 18.03%
2014 62.23% 16.17%
2015 61.54% 14.94%
2016 60.43% 15.10%
2017 59.01% 15.29%
2018 54.20% 16.42%
2019 55.28% 13.65%
2020 63.62% 8.53%
2021 67.28% 4.30%

Most of the other 28% of mortgage borrowers remained in the alternative lending space to fund their properties. These borrowers either changed to another alternative lender or renewed with their initial alternative lender.

While we consider this evidence of an ineffective exit strategy, it is important to note that the borrower could return to the conventional lending space if:

  • the loan was renewed with the same lender
  • the loan was with another alternative lender

Only a very small share of the loans ended in foreclosure.

Foreclosures remain low but higher than for conventional lenders

In the period from 2015 to February 2020, only 0.17% of alternative lender mortgage transactions involved a foreclosure.

During the pandemic (March 2020 to July 2021), the foreclosure rate remained stable (0.08%), representing just 23 properties in Ontario. This, however, does represent a significantly higher foreclosure rate than in the conventional lending space.

Despite accounting for 12% of mortgage transactions, alternative lenders are involved in 65 to 90% of foreclosures each year. This value peaked in 2016 at 88%, due in large part to very few foreclosures occurring in the conventional lending space.

During the pandemic period, this value (71%) remained consistent with the 2017 to 2019 values (74%).

Fewer properties with an alternative mortgage were sold in 2020

During the pandemic, another interesting phenomenon was the decreasing number of properties sold on alternative lenders’ portfolios. This seems to contradict the strong activity in the housing market in Toronto and Ottawa.

Before the pandemic, between 10% and 20% of properties with an alternative mortgage would be sold. However, in 2020, only 8.5% of properties were sold. Possible explanations include:

  • property type
  • property location
  • deferral programs

Support programs, such as mortgage payment deferrals, allowed borrowers to avoid default and, therefore, having to sell their property.

The 2021 data may also be slightly skewed given the lagging in property sales data in the land registry.

Successful exit strategies have decreased since 2011

The success of exit strategies has decreased by 10 percentage points since 2011 and stabilized during the pandemic. This decrease before the pandemic implies that the borrowers served by alternative lenders are remaining in this segment longer than anticipated.

Given the higher interest rates, this may pose long-term affordability issues for these borrowers.

Key definitions

Alternative lenders include mortgage investment entities, mortgage investment corporations, private lenders and individual lenders.

Conventional lenders include chartered banks, credit unions, monolines/mortgage finance companies, trust companies and insurance companies.

Mortgage transactions are activities such as mortgage origination, mortgage switch, mortgage renewal/refinance or mortgage closing.

Footnotes

  1. Findings from the Mortgage Investment Corporation Survey conducted by Fundamentals Research Corp. These can be found in our more recent Residential Mortgage Industry Report
  2. We can assume that a property being sold is not the borrower’s preferred outcome. However, we hypothesize that the borrower selling the property is better off than being entrenched in a high interest-only loan for an extended period or foreclosed on the property.
Previous Alternative Lenders Series

Was this page relevant to your needs?

Thank you for your feedback!

How Can We Help?

Suggest an Improvement

Report a Bug

How Can We Help?

Suggest an Improvement

Please share your suggestion.

Google Captcha Loader

How Can We Help?

Report a Bug

Please describe the problem.

Google Captcha Loader

Thank you. Your feedback has been submitted.

Date Published: June 28, 2022

By Topic

  • Professionals
    • Project funding and mortgage financing
    • Housing markets data and research
    • Industry innovation and leadership
    • Events and speakers
  • Consumers
    • Home buying
    • Owning a home
    • Renting a home

About Us

  • CMHC's Story
  • Management and Governance
  • Our Partners
  • Corporate Reporting
  • Contact Us
  • Careers

More

  • CMHC Newsletters
  • CMHC Library
  • Housing Observer
  • Media Newsroom
  • CMHC and Accessible Housing
  • CMHC on Twitter
  • CMHC on LinkedIn
  • CMHC on Facebook
  • CMHC on Instagram
  • CMHC on YouTube
Privacy Policy    |    Terms and Conditions    |    Transparency    |    Accessibility Plan    |    Accessibility Feedback     Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation (CMHC) ©2025 
Canada
loader icon